A controversial plan to charge drivers for entry to the busiest area of Manhattan has come under significant criticism and drawn-out legal action.
Manhattan Entry Fee Incoming
Starting on June 30, drivers in Manhattan will have to pay a $15 toll to enter the city’s crowded business district, in an effort to ease the area’s heavy congestion.
Congestion Pricing Plan
The date for the aptly named ‘congestion pricing plan’ was announced by city transit officials on Friday, after being first approved by the New York State Legislature in 2019.
Changing Toll Amounts
The $15 fee will be applied to drivers who enter Manhattan south of 60th Street during the day. Toll amounts will fluctuate depending on vehicle size and entrance hours, with larger vehicles charged more and drivers charged less for nighttime entry, among other discounts and exemptions.
Small Vehicles
Passenger vehicles and small commercial vehicles will pay $15 during peak hours and $3.75 at night, while motorcycle riders will pay $7.50 and $1.75.
Larger Vehicles
Trucks will pay $24 during the day and $6 overnight, and buses will pay $36 during the day and $9 overnight. These prices will only apply to EZPass users, whereas non-users will “generally be 50% higher than the E-ZPass rates.”
Discounts for Low-Income Residents
Low-income residents in both New York and New Jersey can apply for enrollment in the Low-Income Discount Plan, which grants a 50% discount after the first 10 trips during the calendar month.
The Congestion Relief Zone
Now called the “Congestion Relief Zone,” the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) estimates that the new toll will reduce traffic by 100,000 vehicles per day.
Plenty of Benefits
Though the toll has been controversial, the MTA has argued for its benefits even beyond congestion relief. The fee collection will be used to fund important city transit projects.
Subway Signal System
One such project is the revamped subway signal system, which would improve train services and make city trains less crowded overall.
“We Are a Mass Transit City”
“We are a mass transit city and we are going to make it even better to be in New York,” said MTA CEO Janno Lieber. “Ninety percent-plus of the people come to the congestion zone, the central business district, walking, biking and most of all taking mass transit.”
Positive Environmental Benefits
Turning from personal vehicles to mass transit systems and other transport options will also help to reduce pollution in the business district, according to Julie Tighe, president of the New York League of Conservation Voters.
Combating the Climate Crisis
“We cannot drive our way out of the climate crisis, and congestion pricing will provide critical funding to upgrade our mass transit system,” Tighe said. “Benefiting the millions of daily commuters across the region and encouraging countless more to ditch their gas-guzzling cars.”
A Large Burden on Drivers
Despite these proclaimed benefits, the congestion pricing plan has come under fire by many who claim it is too large of a burden to place on drivers.
Already Paying Tolls
Many people traveling into Manhattan’s business district by car are already paying tolls to cross bridges and tunnels before they reach the city center.
Risks of Delay Due to Lawsuits
The new congestion pricing plan is now at risk of being delayed or even stopped entirely due to ongoing lawsuits against the MTA. The most notable of which is a lawsuit representing the state of New Jersey.
Awaiting Court Rulings
“We are awaiting a court ruling as early as next month on whether the MTA’s unprecedented congestion pricing scheme can go forward,” said attorney Randy Mastro, who represented the state in federal court this month.
A “Hugely Flawed” Plan?
Mastro described the plan as “hugely flawed” and also pointed out “obvious deficiencies in the environmental review” and “lack of mitigation provided for New Jersey’s environmental justice communities.”
Other Regions Join in
Fort Lee, a borough of New Jersey, and Bergen County, the most populous county in the state, have also filed separate lawsuits of their own.
Lawsuits Pile Up
The MTA has shot back at the mounting number of lawsuits against them, arguing that legal action is hampering their critical transport improvement projects.
Everything On Hold
“Critical improvements to improve our system, expand our system, make it more accessible, all of those improvements are going to have to be on hold while we await the outcome of this litigation,” said Jamie Torres-Springer, current president of the MTA’s construction and development department.
The post Manhattan Hits Drivers With $15 Toll in Busiest Areas first appeared on Liberty & Wealth.
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Luciano Mortula – LGM.
The content of this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute or replace professional financial advice.
