The cafe chain is discontinuing its caffeinated lemonade brand after a number of legal disputes.
End of Charged Sips
Fast casual favorite Panera Bread has announced its plans to phase out a line of controversial drinks known as Charged Sips after they were linked to two wrongful death lawsuits.
Not Addressing the Issue?
The plan was announced in a company statement on Tuesday, however, it did not name any lawsuits or safety concerns as the cause for discontinuing the beverages.
Lawsuits and Health Speculations
Panera first started selling the Charged Sips, a line of caffeine-packed lemonade, back in 2022. Since then the drinks have become the subject of multiple lawsuits in the US, and people have speculated about the health risks associated with the drinks ever since.
More Than Recommended
According to the Panera official website each Charged Sips lemonade contains 155 to 302 milligrams, with health experts recommending no more than 400 milligrams a day for the average person.
Equivalent to 3 Coffees
A single Charged Sips beverage that contains 300 milligrams of caffeine is equivalent to approximately three 8-ounce cups of coffee.
First Lawsuit
In October 2023 a lawsuit was filed against Panera over the death of a 21-year-old student, Sarah Katz, who died of cardiac arrest in September. Her family alleged the death was caused by a Charged Lemonade.
Claims They Are “Unreasonably Dangerous”
Katz’s parents described the Panera Charged Lemonade as “unreasonably dangerous,” due to the high amounts of sugar and caffeine, and accused the company of doing nothing to warn their customers about its contents.
A Tragic Passing
The 21-year-old Ivy League student actively avoided energy drinks due to a life-threatening heart condition. The suit filed by her parents claimed that she did not know that the Charged Lemonade contained high amounts of caffeine.
“Panera Should Have Known”
“Defendants [Panera] knew or should have known that the Panera Charged Lemonade, as designed and formulated, once consumed, could injure children, pregnant and breastfeeding women, and people sensitive to caffeine — including those with underlying heart problems — by causing catastrophic injuries and/or death,” the lawsuit claimed.
Second Case Arises
Just two months after the case, in December, another wrongful death lawsuit was filed against Panera over the cardiac arrest of 46-year-old Florida man David Brown.
A Dangerous Combination
David Brown’s family claimed the death was directly caused by these caffeinated lemonades, as Brown had high blood pressure and allegedly drank three Charged Lemonades in one sitting prior to his heart attack.
Seven Beverages in Two Weeks
What’s more, the specific lawsuit claimed Brown imbibed a minimum of seven Charged Lemonades in the two weeks leading up to his death.
Panera Maintains Innocence
So far Panera has maintained its innocence pertaining to the two lawsuits, describing its drinks as completely safe for consumption. However, it has recently added warnings to its online menu.
New Warning on Online Menu
The descriptions for their blood orange, strawberry lemon mint, and mango yuzu citrus Charged Sips now warn consumers to “Consume in moderation. Not recommended for children, people sensitive to caffeine, pregnant or nursing women.”
No Specific Timeline Yet
The company has not given a specific date for when their Charged Sips line will be removed from menus, but they did introduce a new line of beverages that will replace them.
New Drinks to Replace Them
These newly introduced products would include blueberry lavender lemonade, pomegranate hibiscus tea, citrus punch, and tropical green smoothies. These drinks will be part of Panera’s new focus on “low-sugar and low-caffeine options.”
“Excited to Continue”
“We are excited to continue the success of our recent menu transformation, which began with our core options of sandwiches and salads,” their company statement read.
Sold Behind the Counter
Until they are officially phased out, Caffeinated Sips beverages will be sold behind the counter in all Panera cafes. Prior to this, the drinks were available at the front of the stores for customers to more easily access.
Meeting Demand for Natural Energy Drinks
Panera claimed that the 2022 Charged Sips lineup was created to fulfill a growing demand for energy-boosting drinks made from natural ingredients, as the drinks contain caffeine derived from guarana and green coffee extract.
Capitalizing the Market
But it seemed clear that the beverages were created to address the energy drink in general. Energy drinks make up a $21 million market that is growing year by year, and Charged Sips contain more caffeine than some energy drinks that use non-natural ingredients.
Remote No More: 19 Companies Returning to the Office
As the pandemic wanes, companies are recalling remote workers back to the office, sparking debates on fairness, costs, and convenience. However, there are also notable productivity, coworking, and mental health benefits to consider. Feeling the effects of these changes? Remote No More: 19 Companies Returning to the Office
8 Costco Must Buys and 8 to Leave Behind
Ever wandered Costco’s aisles, questioning if that giant jar of pickles is a real bargain? Or debated buying tires where you get your rotisserie chicken? Welcome to the definitive guide to Costco shopping—a journey to save money, prevent regrets, and offer quirky insights into bulk buying. 8 Costco Must Buys and 8 to Leave Behind
23 Reasons Texas Is the Next Big Thing
Texas is becoming a beacon of opportunity, blending cultural heritage with economic growth. From its landscapes to its industries, the Lone Star State offers a dynamic lifestyle. Here are 23 reasons why Texas stands out, attracting entrepreneurs, artists, tech professionals, and families seeking new beginnings. 23 Reasons Texas Is the Next Big Thing
15 Top Sites to Sell Your Unwanted Goods Besides Craigslist
Selling your unwanted items can declutter your space and boost your income. While Craigslist is popular, there are many alternatives with unique features and wider audiences. Explore these 15 Craigslist alternatives for selling everything from furniture to electronics, finding the perfect platform to turn clutter into cash. 15 Top Sites to Sell Your Unwanted Goods Besides Craigslist
Work from Anywhere: 19 Companies Still Supporting Remote Work
Tired of commuting and craving work flexibility? You’re not alone. Many companies now offer remote work, benefiting both employees and employers. Ever wondered how this shift could enhance your work-life balance? Work from Anywhere: 19 Companies Still Supporting Remote Work
The post – Wrongful Death Lawsuits Halt Panera’s Controversial Caffeine Drinks – first appeared on Liberty & Wealth.
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Jonathan Weiss.
The content of this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute or replace professional financial advice.
